There are some forum icon plugins that help you assign different icons to every forum
But they are 1.6
Please tell me about a working one.
http://mods.mybb.com/view/forum-icons
Open Main Plugin File ficon.php
and find:
"compatibility" => "16*"
and change it to :
"compatibility" => "18*"
I have not tested this on 1.8...just showing you how to change compatibility. It may or may not work