There's people who enjoy social media and then there's people who enjoy forums. Just like how some people use Reddit instead of a forum like HF. Everyone has their choice, just matters that the choice is there.
I'm more of a forum person, I believe social media is for your personal life. I enjoy meeting other people that I may never have to meet or reveal my true identity to online, interacting with them on the forum everyday is enjoyable.
I believe if you intend on having a super successful forum that'll have thousands of people online at a time might not be too easy unless you're like a Market, or Hacking community. However, I do believe that for smaller communities such as Doom.sx, Eternal.is, or Lewd.sx serve there purpose. Small communities for people to gather and enjoy a nice community that keeps itself together.
Fact is forums that run MyBB are dominated by HackForums, LeakForums, OGUsers, etc. The three cover Marketplace and Hacking, so there's no real reason for anyone to join other boards under those topics.
But honestly, if you know what you're doing then I believe you'll achieve success.
Quote:-Don't be an evilĀ Admin
-Develop an Advanced Custom Theme for your Forum
-Offer Social Media styled Functions
-Implement ideas suggested by your community
-Offer creative and fun Plugins and Activities to Engage in onsite
-Provide content for users to enjoy
-Advertise creatively for your forum topic
Some simple keys to a successful forum. Content is king, or more so it use to be. Nowadays a lot of people enjoy a nice design alongside content. Most people do a half job and expect their community to blow up, but I suppose it really just depends on how you manage things.
Quote:I don't think it is unless you have the perfect niche, great developers, and designers.
I can agree with this. The niche doesn't have to be perfect really, it just has to be something you can talk about endlessly on a daily basis. But like you said, great developers and designers are whats crafting the best communities now from what I can tell.
Anyway, I don't know if I answered your question or not but hopefully this'll give you some more thoughts on this, Nasyr.