2007-11-28, 12:54 AM
vB is required for certain forums, MyBB is required for others, and IPB for others. phpBB is never required, nor is SMF :p.
I can honestly say that I have tried all the mainstream and most of the non-mainstream open source software; my favorites? MyBB, vB, and IPB.
I would use IPB if I was making a forum trying to bring in professional business type people. I would use vB if I wanted to please the members with features, over the admins. I would use MyBB for probably everything else, and I do. I own one vB and around 4 other MyBB boards. In my history, I have only owned about 3 vB, probably around 10 MyBB, and 1 IPB. 20 IF but thats when I neither respected nor understood software.
MyBB doesn't have to add a billion features to beat vB. They are already gaining up on them with a ton less features. MyBB had the right idea by keeping things easy for both the admin and user. The necessities are there and then some, and that is what a good board needs. As someone said, all MyBB has to do is get 1.4 out there, but thats not to rival them, thats just because Im too anxious to keep waiting XD.
One more point: I run a vB and every now and then I get a database error which is just no fun. On all the MyBB boards I've run in all my years, NEVER have I had an error. One time I had a polls error that Tikitiki fixed in a second by actually joining my board. (the problem was because the file didn't load when I upgraded, due to the ftp client, not MyBB) vB has good support, MyBB has better support, its a fact, and I don't think many would argue that. There is only one MyBB board that I know of that gets errors, and Im not sure why that is. MyBB is, for the most part, relatively error free when they release.
One final thing regarding vB version releases . They used to release a new .X version weekly. Shoot, IPB was doing it daily a few months ago. I love how when MyBB makes a release, it is what it is, and you don't need to download a patch the next week. Its good for us designers.
I can honestly say that I have tried all the mainstream and most of the non-mainstream open source software; my favorites? MyBB, vB, and IPB.
I would use IPB if I was making a forum trying to bring in professional business type people. I would use vB if I wanted to please the members with features, over the admins. I would use MyBB for probably everything else, and I do. I own one vB and around 4 other MyBB boards. In my history, I have only owned about 3 vB, probably around 10 MyBB, and 1 IPB. 20 IF but thats when I neither respected nor understood software.
MyBB doesn't have to add a billion features to beat vB. They are already gaining up on them with a ton less features. MyBB had the right idea by keeping things easy for both the admin and user. The necessities are there and then some, and that is what a good board needs. As someone said, all MyBB has to do is get 1.4 out there, but thats not to rival them, thats just because Im too anxious to keep waiting XD.
One more point: I run a vB and every now and then I get a database error which is just no fun. On all the MyBB boards I've run in all my years, NEVER have I had an error. One time I had a polls error that Tikitiki fixed in a second by actually joining my board. (the problem was because the file didn't load when I upgraded, due to the ftp client, not MyBB) vB has good support, MyBB has better support, its a fact, and I don't think many would argue that. There is only one MyBB board that I know of that gets errors, and Im not sure why that is. MyBB is, for the most part, relatively error free when they release.
One final thing regarding vB version releases . They used to release a new .X version weekly. Shoot, IPB was doing it daily a few months ago. I love how when MyBB makes a release, it is what it is, and you don't need to download a patch the next week. Its good for us designers.