lol the strange thing is all my previous theme's were darker, that why i have the black background on my logo, but everyone said they hated it.
Well its up to you, find something you like and go with it. my friend hates my current theme but I like it so I am keeping it
GreenFox actually looks bad in practice.
Afresh is overused because it's one of the few seriously slick looking themes for MyBB. The price of success. Afresh can still look great and original if you take the time to customize it.