I can't get the custom forum icons to work for me... please help!
That's a pretty vague explanation to your problem.
What "forum icons" are you referring to?
What do you mean forum icons? Like the on/off/lock icons or different icons distinguishing each forum?
Why not just replace the images initially? A plugin seems sort of dumb.
How do I do that? Because that is a great idea. (I want to make it so different forums have different icons).