Currently I have not re-enabled Fit on Page or While You Were Typing, if these plugins are disabled but not uninstalled, they should not be affecting anything?
I did the analysis you linked mark-in-dallas, and the result was as follows:
Analysis and Recommendations
QTY SIZE# TYPE URL COMMENTS
1 169393 SCRIPT www.vampirecounts.net ... jscripts/prototype.js?... Header size = 312 bytes
Up to 132059 bytes could have been saved through compression.
1 67110 IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... ges/carpe-noctem/logo.php Header size = 590 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
1 52305 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /carpe-noctem/head-bg.jpg Header size = 298 bytes
2 50549 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... rpe-noctem/footer_bg2.gif Header size = 297 bytes
1 49898 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... bfont.svg#webfontQvyKutP1 Header size = 301 bytes
1 30043 SCRIPT ajax.googleapis.com ... /jquery/1.5/jquery.min.js Header size = 373 bytes
Congratulations! This file was compressed.
1 27552 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... onts/cw_bandy-webfont.ttf Header size = 310 bytes
1 18678 SCRIPT www.vampirecounts.net ... t/jscripts/general.js?... Header size = 310 bytes
Up to 13760 bytes could have been saved through compression.
1 17464 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... nts/cw_bandy-webfont.woff Header size = 298 bytes
1 15209 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /cw_bandy-webfont.eot?... Header size = 317 bytes
1 14644 HTML http://www.vampirecounts.net Header size = 743 bytes
Congratulations! This file was compressed.
View a formatted version of this HTML file
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... ctem/english/rateuser.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... m/english/postbit_www.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /english/postbit_warn.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... sh/postbit_reputation.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... nglish/postbit_report.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... lish/postbit_replyall.png Header size = 633 bytes
2 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... english/postbit_quote.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... em/english/postbit_pm.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... sh/postbit_multiquote.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /english/postbit_find.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... english/postbit_email.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /english/postbit_edit.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... nglish/postbit_delete.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... em/english/pm_forward.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... tem/english/pm_delete.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... tem/english/newthread.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... ctem/english/newreply.png Header size = 633 bytes
1 Not found CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... noctem/english/closed.png Header size = 633 bytes
2 20052 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... e-noctem/button-hover.jpg Header size = 298 bytes
2 17699 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... s/carpe-noctem/button.jpg Header size = 298 bytes
1 6016 IMG http://www.warvault.net/webring/button.php?... Header size = 443 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
1 4617 CSS www.vampirecounts.net ... themes/theme10/global.css Header size = 340 bytes
Congratulations! This file was compressed.
View a formatted version of this CSS file
2 3952 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /carpe-noctem/li-desc.png Header size = 295 bytes
1 3847 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... s/carpe-noctem/search.png Header size = 295 bytes
1 3286 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... ctem/border-top-right.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 3271 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... m/border-bottom-right.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 3250 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... octem/border-top-left.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 3247 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... em/border-bottom-left.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 3047 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /border-bottom-middle.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 3015 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... es/carpe-noctem/arrow.png Header size = 295 bytes
1 2978 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... tem/border-top-middle.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 2799 SCRIPT www.vampirecounts.net ... ctem/jscripts/theme-js.js Header size = 308 bytes
Up to 1938 bytes could have been saved through compression.
1 2755 SCRIPT www.vampirecounts.net ... scripts/popup_menu.js?... Header size = 308 bytes
Up to 1841 bytes could have been saved through compression.
1 1542 CSS IMG http://www.vampirecounts.net/images/spinner.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 1506 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... carpe-noctem/left-bar.gif Header size = 295 bytes
1 1503 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... arpe-noctem/right-bar.gif Header size = 295 bytes
39 1101 IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... mages/carpe-noctem/on.gif Header size = 295 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
1 1013 CSS IMG http://www.vampirecounts.net/images/error.gif Header size = 295 bytes
2 876 IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... arpe-noctem/no-avatar.gif Header size = 294 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
3 748 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... carpe-noctem/thead_bg.gif Header size = 294 bytes
1 746 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... arpe-noctem/footer_bg.gif Header size = 294 bytes
2 698 IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /carpe-noctem/offlock.gif Header size = 294 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
4 698 IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... ages/carpe-noctem/off.gif Header size = 294 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
1 632 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... carpe-noctem/inbox_bg.gif Header size = 294 bytes
1 594 CSS IMG http://www.vampirecounts.net/images/invalid.gif Header size = 294 bytes
1 541 CSS IMG http://www.vampirecounts.net/images/valid.gif Header size = 294 bytes
10 525 IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... carpe-noctem/collapse.gif Header size = 294 bytes
Missing width attribute.
Missing height attribute.
1 370 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... /carpe-noctem/menu_bg.gif Header size = 294 bytes
1 318 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... e-noctem/searchbox_bg.gif Header size = 294 bytes
1 289 CSS IMG http://www.vampirecounts.net/images/jump.gif Header size = 294 bytes
1 242 CSS www.vampirecounts.net ... arpe-noctem/font-face.css Header size = 338 bytes
Congratulations! This file was compressed.
View a formatted version of this CSS file
1 190 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... e-noctem/border-right.gif Header size = 293 bytes
1 188 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... pe-noctem/border-left.gif Header size = 293 bytes
1 176 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... -noctem/bottommenu_bg.gif Header size = 293 bytes
1 157 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... carpe-noctem/tfoot_bg.gif Header size = 293 bytes
2 144 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... s/carpe-noctem/nav_bg.gif Header size = 293 bytes
1 126 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... e-noctem/theadname_bg.gif Header size = 293 bytes
1 89 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... rpe-noctem/border-top.gif Header size = 292 bytes
1 89 CSS IMG www.vampirecounts.net ... -noctem/border-bottom.gif Header size = 292 bytes
TOTAL_HTML - Congratulations, the total number of HTML files on this page (including the main HTML file) is 1 which most browsers can multithread. Minimizing HTTP requests is key for web site optimization. Y
TOTAL_OBJECTS - Warning! The total number of objects on this page is 70 which by their number will dominate web page delay. Consider reducing this to a more reasonable number. Above 20 objects per page the overhead from dealing with the actual objects (description time and wait time) accounts for more than 80% of whole page latency. See Figure II-3: Relative distribution of latency components showing that object overhead dominates web page latency in Website Optimization Secrets for more details on how object overhead dominates web page latency. Combine, refine, and optimize your external objects. Replace graphic rollovers with CSS rollovers to speed display and minimize HTTP requests. Consider using CSS sprites to help consolidate decorative images. Using CSS techniques such as colored backgrounds, borders, or spacing instead of graphic techniques can reduce HTTP requests. Replace graphic text headers with CSS text headers to further reduce HTTP requests. Finally, consider optimizing parallel downloads by using different hostnames or a CDN to reduce object overhead.
TOTAL_IMAGES - Warning! The total number of images on this page is 62 , consider reducing this to a more reasonable number. Recommend combining, replacing, and optimizing your graphics. Replace graphic rollover menus with CSS rollover menus to speed display and minimize HTTP requests. Consider using CSS sprites to help consolidate decorative images. Use CSS techniques such as colored backgrounds, borders, or spacing instead of graphic techniques to reduce HTTP requests. Replace graphic text headers with CSS text headers to further reduce HTTP requests. Finally, consider optimizing parallel downloads by using different hostnames to reduce object overhead.
TOTAL_CSS - Congratulations, the total number of external CSS files on this page is 2 . Because external CSS files must be in the HEAD of your HTML document, they must load first before any BODY content displays. Although they are cached, CSS files slow down the initial display of your page. Remember to place CSS files in the HEAD and JavaScript files at the end of the BODY to enable progressive display.
TOTAL_SIZE - Warning! The total size of this page is 611777 bytes, which will load in 135.93 seconds on a 56Kbps modem. Consider reducing total page size to less than 100K to achieve sub 20 second response times on 56K connections. Pages over 100K exceed most attention thresholds at 56Kbps, even with feedback. Consider optimizing your site with Website Optimization Secrets, Speed Up Your Site or contacting us about our optimization services.
TOTAL_SCRIPT - Caution. The total number of external script files on this page is 5 , consider reducing this to one or two. Combine, refactor, and minify to optimize your JavaScript files. Ideally you should have one (or even embed scripts for high-traffic pages) on your pages. Consider suturing JavaScript files together at the server to minimize HTTP requests. Placing external JavaScript files at the bottom of your BODY, and CSS files in the HEAD enables progressive display in XHTML web pages.
HTML_SIZE - Congratulations, the total size of this HTML file is 14644 bytes, which less than 50K. Assuming that you specify the HEIGHT and WIDTH of your images, this size allows your HTML to display content in under 10 seconds, the average time users are willing to wait for a page to display without feedback.
IMAGES_SIZE - Warning! The total size of your images is 368606 bytes, which is over 100K. Consider switch graphic formats to achive smaller file sizes (from JPEG to PNG for example). Finally, substitute CSS techniques for graphics techniques to create colored borders, backgrounds, and spacing.
SCRIPT_SIZE - Warning! The total size of external your scripts is 223668 bytes, which is over 20K. Consider optimizing your JavaScript for size, combining them, and using HTTP compression where appropriate for any scripts placed in the HEAD of your documents. You can substitute CSS menus for JavaScript-based menus to minimize or even eliminate the use of JavaScript.
CSS_SIZE - Congratulations, the total size of your external CSS is 4859 bytes, which is less than 8K.
MULTIM_SIZE - Congratulations, the total size of all your external multimedia files is 0 bytes, which is less than 10K.
So it does suggest the theme I suppose. I will have to go back to the designers about it.