Jump to the post that solved this thread.
Not Solved Quick question regarding merging two forums..
#1
Not Solved
Hi, I have a quick question regarding merging 2 forums, one of which having been converted from "Touch-a-chat" which runs an old version of PhpBB 3.2.0.. but was converted to MyBB 1.8.38..

As I said, I have 2 forums that will be merged..

Forum A was converted and so far, all posts and stuff has been accounted for.. that I can tell from the sections whose permissions I've restored so far..

Forum B is my main forum, that has been established and running since I came here back in 2014.. and as such, will be the forum that Forum A will be merged into..

With these details out of the way, here is my question..

Does Forum A's sections need to be accessible to all groups for that forum, if I am just going to be merging it into Forum B, or can I just make the areas accessible to only the admins so that I can see the areas myself and move the content into the existing areas of Forum B?

I ask because I've spent several days (and nights) talking back and forth between both hosts for not only securing my late-brother's db from T.A.C. and then setting up the merge system with help from the second host, and after a mini fatigue-induced meltdown resulting in some tears and a renewed focus on getting this conversion done, I finally did it.

Yay. (Or so I thought..)

After going through this on next to no sleep, and finally getting it done, I realized that I now had to set granular permissions for a forum that had 80+ sections and about 2 or 3 dozen groups for them, that will ultimately end up being merged into mine anyway..

And, much like the very beginning of my decision to go with paid hosting on MyBB from my previous free IPB host, the more I work on this forum trying to set the permissions for these areas and groups, the more I want to stop, merge the 2 forums as they are, so that I can continue work on my main forum and resolving the issues it has..

So I am asking in a nutshell, if Forum A, has to be pretty much set up like Forum B in terms of all groups having access to the sections, or can I just get away with a "quick and dirty" version where the admins group only has access so that I can just move the converted content to the existing sections of Forum B.

I have these installations set in 3 directories on my server. 

1. Converted T.A.C. db. (Forum A)

2. Copy of main forum's db on a clean install of MyBB with 0 plugins. (Copy of Forum B)

3. Main forum, with all plugins, and the bugs and FUBAR'D templates to show for it..

My goal at the end of this, is to merge both dbs using the clean install location and then once everything is properly set up and the merged content being in the new sections, then I will take a back up of everything and then wipe the main forum install, and install a clean copy of MyBB, so that, I can then restore the combined forum to the original location and then start adding the plugins.. 

Once I have finished converting my themes to be mobile friendly.. I am simply trying to minimize the back and forth between these installations.

Thank you in advance for the help, I truly appreciate it.. Smile
Thank you in advance for your time, and as always I appreciate any help offered.

List of unsolved MyBB Support issues.. 

https://community.mybb.com/search.php?ac...&uid=81844
Reply
#2
Not Solved
Hi Black Angel,

You've produced quite a bit of input for a quick question Wink , some of it in a font size I can no longer read.

I've only used the merge system once and therefore don't have much experience with it, but I don't think posts from the forum being imported will be transferred to existing subforums of the main forum.
Users, categories, forums, etc. will be added to the main forum. Correct me, supporters, if I'm completely wrong, but that's my memory of my merge from over two years ago.

Afterward, you as an admin will have to do some follow-up work to get the forums and posts into the appropriate format.

I created a copy of the main forum back then to identify and fix any potential problems in a test run before tackling the final merge with the running board (closing it first, of course).

I hope others have more experience and can give you more detailed information.

best regards
Lu
Support ended!
Reply
#3
Not Solved
Hi Lu, thank you for the timely response, and sorry about the mini brain-dump but I wanted to be as specific as possible about my situation before I hit the hay for the night.. so I apologize for the confusion..

Anyway, thank you for sharing your experience with the Merge system, it is helpful, but I was asking if ALL the sections of Forum A had to be open and accessible to ALL usergroups, if I were ONLY going to merge that forum into Forum B, or could I slide by just opening Forum A's sections to the admin group only, so that I could then move the content into the existing sections of Forum B.

I am hoping that what I am asking is ok, because the idea of having to set individual permissions of the 20+ usergroups my brother had, for each of his forum's 90+ sections makes me want to cry..

Again.. lol

Our forum was pretty much a general forum with an artistic, animation and gaming community attached and we merged years ago because he liked the mature topics at my forum and wanted to expand his community by merging with mine.. so I am in essence, trying to get the band back together so to speak..

So the general chat sections would be re-absorbed into my forum while his sections would be the new category or two..

For example, when you merged your forums years ago, did you have to make sure that ALL sections of your Forum A (the one you were merging into your Forum B) were open to ALL groups before you merged it, or did you just open up Forum A for your staff groups to access so that you could then move the content from Forum A, into the existing sections of Forum B..

I hope this makes sense..
Thank you in advance for your time, and as always I appreciate any help offered.

List of unsolved MyBB Support issues.. 

https://community.mybb.com/search.php?ac...&uid=81844
Reply
#4
Not Solved
Hi Black Angel,

Sorry, I wasn't quite awake this morning when I read your post, and after all, it's still a foreign language to me Wink
It's good that you're breaking down the problem thoroughly. Far too often, you read one-sentence posts in support from people asking questions that don't even begin to describe the problem. I thought it was funny that you called it a quick question. As you can see, I'm not good at short writing either.

I see it this way: for the merge, the entire forum is closed to everyone, so it doesn't matter which group has visibility. You only open it again when it's appropriate.
The group configuration of your brother, who died too soon, sounds truly horrific; I also had a complicated group system, but not to this extent, phew!

Back then, I set the access rights for the integrated forum just for me as the admin and then checked with my test account whether everything was correctly visible only to the admin. The forum I was integrating, however, was also quite simple in terms of structure and group permissions. This allowed me to reopen it fairly quickly and work in the background.

One more thought: since none of your old users is in any of the newly added user groups from your brother's forum, there shouldn't be any access there anyway.

It definitely makes sense to think things through thoroughly beforehand, and as I said, I always prefer a test run with things like this to identify and solve problems in advance.
Especially the paths to the attachments and avatars should already be worked out. I remember tweaking them a bit back then.

And now I've probably missed a lot and written a lot of nonsense again, but for me, a too-long workday as an author is just coming to an end. My fingers will keep typing all night Wink At least it was a productive day, I'm not complaining!

good night...
Lu
Support ended!
Reply
#5
Not Solved
Oh ok.. thanks for the info. Smile

So, since my last post, I kinda sorta let my curiosity get the better of me and after opening the sections to admins only on Forum A, I took a back up and then merged it into Forum B and it imported everything without issue and I can easily move the content where it needs to go.. the new forums are listed beneath the existing ones but most importantly, I did not have to open the sections to all groups for Forum A.. so in this case, I was able to do a quick and dirty merge without issue.

That said, I do have some duplicate accounts that have the accounts user name with mybb_import123 added to the end of the name, so it looks like "Username_mybb_import123" so I need to know how I can merge these accounts and data with their originals.. or at least do so via PhpMyAdmin..

Have you encountered this issue?
Thank you in advance for your time, and as always I appreciate any help offered.

List of unsolved MyBB Support issues.. 

https://community.mybb.com/search.php?ac...&uid=81844
Reply
#6
Not Solved
Great news, congratulations

You can merge users via ACP --> Users & Groups --> Merge Users

I didn't have that problem; there were no user overlaps, but it's interesting to see how the merge system handles it.
Support ended!
Reply
#7
Not Solved
Hi, I am not sure if this is a bug or not, but I am currently still reorganizing the merged sections and the topics in them, on my forum, (Friday night, I shut down my forum and just did the merge, because working on separate installs was exhausting and the more I continued, the less I wanted to do it, so I just ripped the band aid off and just got it done..)

That said, I just wanted to post back and say that although the content seems to be accounted for except for avatars and attachments, despite the directories having the right chmod settings, the topics that were migrated over, do not have titles.. the merge was smooth, apart from some php warnings regarding a few plugins..

For example, let's say the topic in question is "Italian Recipes" the topic itself will have all of the content, including the title, but if I were to try and edit the post and then save it, it will give me an error that says that the post needs a title, and if I scroll up, the title box will be empty.

So if you had to edit the first post of that merged "Italian Recipes" topic for whatever reason, then you would have to copy the title before you edit it, so that you can save the title into the original post after you save your changes..

I noticed this issue when I saw that some posts were blank and I had to copy the missing info from the original forum and edit the post with the missing content, and then save it..
Thank you in advance for your time, and as always I appreciate any help offered.

List of unsolved MyBB Support issues.. 

https://community.mybb.com/search.php?ac...&uid=81844
Reply
Jump to the post that solved this thread.


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)