Thought it was 2 posts, but ...
#1
In the thread about web scrappers/bots/web crawlers, I thought I was doing a second post, but it seems something triggered an interesting combining of the posts.

I suppose I don't mind that (this time) but I do not recall seeing that mechanism on previous sites/platforms.

And am wondering how that is triggered?

I did use the search tool here, but phrasing that is difficult and no results provided any hints.

This should show you the post:
https://community.mybb.com/thread-244341...pid1404518

Would thank you for help in understanding that and don't mind grabbing cache info, if needed. Thank you.
Reply
#2
See in the ACP under Configuration » Settings » Posting » Post Merge Time ("With this enabled, posts posted within x minutes by the same author right after each other, will be merged. Set the time limit (in minutes) to merge posts. Set to 0 to disable this feature. Default: 60").
Reply
#3
It's an anti-spam feature.
No longer involved in the MyBB project.
Reply
#4
My goodness, my English is getting really bad --- "merge" --- how come my old brain didn't remember that vocabulary.

Anyway, I appreciate the answers. Makes sense, too. Just don't remember having seen that sort of code in the past. BUT, it has been over a decade since I last messed about with these platforms and I reckon that spam trouble has gotten worse since back a decade or so ago.

Anyway, kind of neat to have a computer program surprise me like that.

I don't think I saw any pop-up indicating that would happen. You know, like: "Are you sure you want to merge with your previous post?" Of course, I might have been careless and didn't see the pop-up.

Is that information located where we'd easily notice? (And I missed it.)

EDIT: Just took a look at my records and the setting here is way faster than 60 minutes. Maybe set at 10 or 15 minutes?
Reply
#5
There's no warning because it's non-optional. It's designed so you can't post that fast, and the alternative would be not letting you post at all which is sub-optimal.
No longer involved in the MyBB project.
Reply
#6
(2025-11-06, 11:04 AM)Nathan Malcolm Wrote: There's no warning because it's non-optional. It's designed so you can't post that fast, and the alternative would be not letting you post at all which is sub-optimal.

But this protocol isn't standard on all forum platforms, correct? You don't reckon it would be polite to newbies to let them know about this? Just a first thought as I digest the information.

Let's see, last admin work I did was on phpBB and we didn't have that option back 10 or so years ago. I've recently posted on a SimpleMachines platform and don't think I ran into that. Had a long run on one of VerticalScope's sites during some studies and don't remember ever hitting that.

Is this a recent code change for MyBB?

I get that point about anti-spam; but I also feel a certain degree of politeness is due to Community Citizens. Sort of makes me think of a traffic light without the yellow warning light --- just BAM 'red' light.

And may I ask what is the setting here?

Well, now I think about this; what if I wanted to quote and respond to two different members in the same thread and do it quickly? Would that also trigger this protocol? Now that might cause some unpleasant reaction/feelings from a newbie. Just another thought as I digest the information.
Reply
#7
(2025-11-06, 11:37 AM)scealc Wrote:
(2025-11-06, 11:04 AM)Nathan Malcolm Wrote: There's no warning because it's non-optional. It's designed so you can't post that fast, and the alternative would be not letting you post at all which is sub-optimal.

But this protocol isn't standard on all forum platforms, correct? You don't reckon it would be polite to newbies to let them know about this? Just a first thought as I digest the information.

Let's see, last admin work I did was on phpBB and we didn't have that option back 10 or so years ago. I've recently posted on a SimpleMachines platform and don't think I ran into that. Had a long run on one of VerticalScope's sites during some studies and don't remember ever hitting that.

Is this a recent code change for MyBB?

I get that point about anti-spam; but I also feel a certain degree of politeness is due to Community Citizens. Sort of makes me think of a traffic light without the yellow warning light --- just BAM 'red' light.

And may I ask what is the setting here?

Well, now I think about this; what if I wanted to quote and respond to two different members in the same thread and do it quickly? Would that also trigger this protocol? Now that might cause some unpleasant reaction/feelings from a newbie. Just another thought as I digest the information.
That's what the multi quote is for. If you want to quote more than one post in a thread,just click the quote button on each post and you can reply to all of them at once.
[Image: createmybb-signature.png]
Reply
#8
(2025-11-06, 11:37 AM)scealc Wrote: Is this a recent code change for MyBB?

Since 2008.
No longer involved in the MyBB project.
Reply
#9
Hope I'll be excused for being slow with the thought process on this, but last night as I was starting to shut off work for sleep it hit me that the idea of that configuration stopping spam is a tad weird. All it did was merge my previous post with a second post and that second post fell within a time parameter set for this platform. How would that stop a spammer? What am I missing?

In fact, it seems to me a clever spammer could make use of that configuration and really spam the heck out of a thread, especially if that pro-spammer had already figured out when the Mod Team was most likely not on the site.

<><><><><><><><>

AND, that multi-quote idea I see posted a bit up may not always be such a good idea. A Community Citizen may want to purposely separate responses to two different members. Sure, it would then be said that is too bad. If you don't like it then bye-bye. That is way too much what we receive from some management teams. In fact, one big reason why I have made some important decisions about this software (important only for myself and my team) --- but that was because I sensed an unusual attitude in management here --- a "We care." attitude here by management. That "We care." style is long gone on a majority of Net sites and at Net companies. Sure, still displayed/announced/etc. by all of those entities, but just empty text and images. When the chips are down it is stomp on that one. Get her/him out of here.

One other thought process came to me as I was processing this last night - speed. I see those younger folks using those Star Trek thingies to get their Net work done and they are in a hurry and can go fast with those fingers and sort of make that little computer dance. And that could very well be a new member to this Community and they are rushing and that happens because they are using their machine so fast and may not even notice at first they had two posts merged by the configuration set up here. They come back later that day and see that and are sort of wondering what the heck happened. In 2008 'speed' with a little machine like that android thing wasn't such a big deal.

Try not to take offence, please; anyone. Just giving the whole picture a good look. Well, trying to. I'm not meaning to be contentious or rile up anyone. Just trying to get a good look at the landing site before the skids/wheels touch down. Don't want a blade strike.
Reply
#10
The feature being discussed isn't only about SPAM, it is also about FLOOD. They may be similar but are different.

Also consider, forums are not chat rooms in the classical sense, so you can plan your content for a single post or simply wait long enough to create a new one. I'm sure there won't be much difference because people usually don't sit around waiting for other people to respond.

Administrators can also configure this by group on their forums.

Regards.
Send me a DM or PM if you want to sponsor any update or addition to my plugins.

[Image: signature.png]

Discord omar.gonzalez (Omar G.#6117); Telegram at @omarugc;
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)