(2011-09-11, 08:32 PM)FooFighter Wrote: I "like" this thread, therfore I "Thumbs UP" it.
I "like" this thread, therfore I "Star" it.
Five stars is a more flexible scale than the simple like/dislike. My approach is that I rate (with stars) the
subject of the thread (and thus the average rating by many users is calculated), while I thumb up/down the individual posts within the thread.
For example, the thread is dedicated to the album "Ride the Lightning" by Metallica. It collects 4 or 5 stars from all the users, thus gaining the average rating of, say, 4,78 (btw, this is quite informative for the listeners yet unacquainted with Metallica). The users leave posts in the thread about what they think of this album. Then some guy comes in and posts something inappropriate about Metallica, and he immediately collects a number of thumb dislikes.
Thus we differentiate the rating of the
thread subject from the "rating" (read - likes/dislikes) of
what folks say about the subject.
If the thread was liked/disliked instead, this would not allow to calculate the average rating.