I said myBB offers great features but SMF is where I felt permissions and admin control excel. I think that's pretty straight forward and a sufficient reason as to why I believe SMF is overall better. Is that not clear? Someone? Any review involves scrapping details together and calling it better.
I realize I'm on a myBB forum board and everyone here uses myBB. So me saying I felt SMF had better admin control is like wearing a KKK suit to harlem. But the fact of the matter is, and I've been testing both forums out, and I still feel that SMF has better admin control.
Now if we're talking about features and only features, sure myBB takes the cake. But I'm talking about control, options, and ease of use.
Here let me be even more specific.
Lets talk about Plugins versus Mods. Now yes, I admit I don't have a great deal of experience with plugins. So this is coming from a first timer looking at the plugin ACP for the first time. Let me say that again cause I KNOW someone missed it.
This is coming from a first timer looking at the plugin ACP for the first time. That means, by default, I don't know what the heck I'm doing and thus, this piece is based on impression and thoughts.
If you look at the top of your screen right now, all the way up at the top of this page, there's a little link called "Mods". In that section you can download mods! Known as plugins in myBB right? Am I wrong?
Ok, so I download one. Now lets install that nice new mod! I go to my ACP... are you still with me here dear?
I go to my ACP and I click on "Plugins" under the Configuration tab. Is this where I am supposed to be? As a first timer, this is where I assume I am supposed to be. Because I don't see anything anywhere else that says, "Mods, Install Mods, This is where you install that mod you just downloaded", etc... Now maybe I'm wrong and this is not the place I'm supposed to go. In that case, someone correct me please! But here I am, looking at the Plugins screen.
Hmm, I see two so far. Akismet which apparently isn't installed and activated (because it says "Install and Activate") and "Hello World!" (which btw from reading the description, I still don't understand what it does). Anyway, moving on. I click on "Plugin Updates" just to see what's there. "Congratulations, all of your plugins are up to date." Awesome! I like that feature btw and is something SMF is lacking.
Ok so the only tab I see that is left is the "Browse Plugins" tab. So there I go. We're still on the same page right? I see a list of (let me count them) 10 plugins I can download off of that page. Hmm, seems cool but none of them are the mod I just downloaded. So lets see... what exactly do I do with this mod I downloaded. I look around for a "Install mod/plugin" or something similar to that. Hmm, not finding it just yet. Maybe I'm in the wrong area. Let me look around other places. "Tools and Maintenance" > "Task Manager", doesn't seem to be it. "Themes and Styles" This has to be it right? Hmm.. ah Import theme! Wait, I don't think this is a theme, it's a mod. Would this work? I don't want to break the forum or anything. Blah, lets try it out.
"The following errors were encountered:
MyBB could not find the theme with the file you uploaded. Please check the file is the correct and is not corrupt."
Ah, well I tried. Lets look elsewhere. "Usergroups" I don't think so. "Forums and Posts" nope not it. "Home"... ah! "Plugins" There I go! Wait... it's the same menu as from before. Well this has to be it because I'm not seeing anything else that may be it. But I can't find out how to actually install this. Alright let's try to download one of those plugins instead. Lets click one... wait... d'oh! It took me to the download page for that plugin! So basically I'm going to download it, and then try to figure out how to install it again.
Now maybe it's just the mod I downloaded, but there's no readme file or help file within the mod. My last option, search this site itself for help on how to install plugins. Which I just did. Ok so I see that on the wiki, it says to upload the plugin to a folder first. Awesome! Now that I know how to do it, it is pretty easy. But here is the thing. I literally went through all of those steps first.
Should I even bother to mention how SMF does it since you're so experienced? I'll save the space and forgo how much more simple it is in SMF.
Lets move on to another topic but lets stay within the realm of customizing your forum.
The next logical step in customizing your look is a new theme! Ok well at least I know how to set that one now because I found it while trying the plugin. So lets do it together. I'm going to walk you through just like I did with the plugins on how the process works for a first timer nublet like myself.
Ok first, lets find a theme!
I search this site for one. Ok I found the themes in the mod page with no issues, so far so good. For quick sake I'm going to just pick the very first theme which for me is
1point6. Alright I DLed it without any issues, lets install this thing!
I head on over to Templates and Style. Alright I see the "Import a Theme". "Choose File" / find the zip file / rename to "My Test Theme" / "Import Theme"
"The following errors were encountered:
MyBB could not find the theme with the file you uploaded. Please check the file is the correct and is not corrupt."
Well damn, I wasn't expecting that. Maybe that theme is crap. Lets try something else.
A Royal Blue Theme is the next one on the list for me.
DL no problem, back to import theme, choose file, import..
"The following errors were encountered:
MyBB could not find the theme with the file you uploaded. Please check the file is the correct and is not corrupt."
Damn, two in a row? Am I doing something wrong? Lets check that wiki again. Ah, looks like I need to throw the files into the server directory first. Same as the plugins I should have figured that.
Hmm, but you do remember how it was with SMF right?
Alright that was just customization of the forum. Honestly, I don't care about the plugins and themes. Those are not what is going to drive my choice of forum software because we have a designer which is making our own custom theme and recoding it to include our options based on our "Nvision Dreams" program. Thus, we will not have to install a single plugin or download anyone's theme. The forum will act how we want because the entire forum script is going to be re-written.
But those are just two examples of what I am talking about with permissions and user control. If you want to have some sort of pissing contest then you win since you can stand up. I really don't care. I'm trying to figure out which software has the best control not who has the better smelling flowers.
Now please, if you have like actual admin controls or something that you would like to compare with SMF then I am all ears. I've been all ears. The thing is most of you are just pushing back because you felt I hurt your pride and your forum choice. You have yet to state a single instance or key structure with myBB in how it surpasses SMF. In fact, if anyone here has given myBB the most props and praise, it's been me.
And as I said before, I now have a whole week to spare on learning myBB. So my original statement of "we choose SMF software instead" is now null and void. I'm very very eager to learn myBB and see what it is about this forum software that I am missing out on. I might choose it at the end, I don't know.
So how about pointing me in the right direction instead of saying my opinion is wrong because I'm an idiot. You say you used SMF and myBB and you love myBB. But did you ever say why? "Lack of ability" helps me none.
PS- all of those steps I took you through to install the plugin and theme, I was literally doing them while I was typing this reply. I wanted to make it clear what I was doing when I was doing it and what I was thinking as I was doing it, because that is the truth behind it. As experienced people you begin to forget what it was like when you were new. As a new person to both SMF and myBB, I felt SMF was easier to understand (in the admin panel).